Evidence before conclusion
Findings should follow the evidentiary record. The desired outcome of a case must never determine the analysis.
The International Sanctions Delisting Commission is an independent non-governmental platform examining whether the continued application of sanctions remains supported by current evidence and circumstances.
“We do not decide who should be sanctioned. We examine whether sanctions should continue. ”
Restrictive measures may remain in force for years while the factual, legal and evidentiary landscape around a designation continues to change.
New judicial findings may emerge. Relationships and ownership structures may change. Evidence relied upon at the time of designation may acquire new context, become outdated, or be supplemented by later information.
ISDC was established to provide a structured framework for examining those developments. The purpose is not to challenge the legitimacy of sanctions as a policy instrument, but to examine whether their continued application to a particular subject remains supported by the current record.
Findings should follow the evidentiary record. The desired outcome of a case must never determine the analysis.
A continuing designation should be examined against present circumstances, not solely against the conditions that existed when sanctions were first imposed.
Review conclusions must remain independent from applicants, funders, governments, political interests and the preferred outcome of any external party.
Published assessments should make clear what was examined, what evidence was material and how the resulting conclusion was reached.
Each case is considered through a consistent analytical framework while remaining responsive to the specific legal and factual circumstances of the designation.
The subject, jurisdiction, designation and available record are identified and the scope of review is established.
Official materials, judicial records, subsequent developments and relevant publicly available evidence are examined.
The continuing applicability of the designation grounds is assessed against current circumstances and available evidence.
Where the record permits a conclusion, ISDC publishes an assessment and one of its defined recommendation outcomes.
The usefulness of an independent review depends not only on the quality of its evidence, but on the integrity of the process that evaluates it. ISDC therefore separates review conclusions from the interests of applicants, funders and external stakeholders and publishes institutional standards governing its work.