Independent non-governmental review institution International
International Sanctions Delisting Commission Independent Sanctions Review
Review Framework

Evidence before conclusion.

ISDC applies a structured methodology to determine whether the factual, evidentiary and legal basis for an existing sanctions designation remains materially applicable under present circumstances.

Core Principle
“We do not decide who should be sanctioned. We examine whether sanctions should continue.”

The review starts from the existing legal designation. It does not assume that the original decision was either correct or incorrect, and it does not assume that delisting is warranted.

01 / REVIEW QUESTIONS

Four questions structure every review.

Each case is examined against the same core analytical framework. The questions are sequential, but evidence may affect more than one part of the assessment.

01
What were the official grounds for designation?
The review begins with the legal acts, listing reasons and official record — not with media characterisations.
02
What evidence supported those grounds?
ISDC identifies the evidence capable of supporting each material element of the designation.
03
What has materially changed since designation?
Subsequent judgments, factual developments, relationships, ownership, conduct and other relevant circumstances are examined.
04
Do the grounds remain sufficiently supported today?
The final question concerns continued application under the present evidentiary record — not merely the historical basis.
02 / PROCESS

From designation to assessment.

ISDC separates collection, verification, analysis and conclusion so that the desired outcome does not determine the evidentiary process.

01
Establish

Official Record

Identify the applicable sanctions acts, stated grounds, designation history and relevant jurisdiction.

02
Verify

Evidence

Separate verified facts, official records, judicial findings and corroborated evidence from unsupported assertion.

03
Compare

Changed Circumstances

Compare the original basis with subsequent legal, factual and evidentiary developments.

04
Determine

Current Assessment

Determine whether the present record supports maintaining the designation, delisting or further review.

03 / EVIDENCE

Not all evidence carries equal weight.

Evidence is assessed for authority, reliability, relevance, specificity, corroboration and temporal proximity to the issue being examined.

Evidentiary Inputs
A
Official legal record
Regulations, decisions, listing acts and official notices.
B
Judicial record
Judgments, orders, appeals and findings of competent courts.
C
Primary documentation
Corporate, regulatory, financial or other directly verifiable records.
D
Corroborated public sources
Reliable reporting and research where material claims can be independently evaluated.
Review
Test
Assessment Factors
Authority Primary
Reliability Tested
Relevance Material
Corroboration Cross-check
Currency Current
The bars illustrate the dimensions of assessment, not fixed numerical scores. ISDC does not mechanically assign a percentage to evidence.
04 / MATERIALITY

Change must be material — not merely new.

A development matters when it is capable of affecting the factual or evidentiary basis for continued designation.

Incidental Relevant Material
The question is not whether something has happened since designation. The question is whether that development meaningfully alters the basis on which continued restrictive measures can be justified.
01
Does it affect a stated ground?
The development must connect to a material element of the designation.
02
Can it be independently verified?
Assertions alone do not establish a material change.
03
Is the change substantive?
Formal or cosmetic changes are distinguished from substantive changes in circumstance.
04
Does it remain relevant today?
The assessment considers both the occurrence and continuing significance of the development.
05 / OUTCOME

The evidence determines the direction.

ISDC does not begin a review with a preferred recommendation. Each case may lead to one of four defined outcomes.

Final Review Test
Does the present record sufficiently support continued designation?
↓
Outcome 01

Recommend Delisting

The current evidentiary record no longer sufficiently supports continued designation under the reviewed grounds.
=
Outcome 02

Recommend Maintaining Designation

The available evidence continues to materially support the relevant grounds for designation.
↻
Outcome 03

Further Review Required

Material issues remain unresolved and additional evidence or analysis is necessary before a conclusion can be reached.
?
Outcome 04

Insufficient Evidence to Reach a Conclusion

The available record does not permit a sufficiently reliable conclusion in either direction.
06 / INDEPENDENCE

Methodology only works if the review is independent.

The applicant does not control the conclusion.

Acceptance of information, communication with an applicant or the opening of a review does not create an obligation to recommend delisting. The same evidentiary standards apply regardless of who submitted the case.

01
No predetermined recommendation.
02
Material conflicts must be identified and managed.
03
Findings must be traceable to the reviewed record.
04
Judicial decisions are respected but not misrepresented as broader findings than they contain.
Review Access

Circumstances change. The evidentiary basis should remain reviewable.