Official Record
Identify the applicable sanctions acts, stated grounds, designation history and relevant jurisdiction.
ISDC applies a structured methodology to determine whether the factual, evidentiary and legal basis for an existing sanctions designation remains materially applicable under present circumstances.
“We do not decide who should be sanctioned. We examine whether sanctions should continue.”
The review starts from the existing legal designation. It does not assume that the original decision was either correct or incorrect, and it does not assume that delisting is warranted.
Each case is examined against the same core analytical framework. The questions are sequential, but evidence may affect more than one part of the assessment.
ISDC separates collection, verification, analysis and conclusion so that the desired outcome does not determine the evidentiary process.
Identify the applicable sanctions acts, stated grounds, designation history and relevant jurisdiction.
Separate verified facts, official records, judicial findings and corroborated evidence from unsupported assertion.
Compare the original basis with subsequent legal, factual and evidentiary developments.
Determine whether the present record supports maintaining the designation, delisting or further review.
Evidence is assessed for authority, reliability, relevance, specificity, corroboration and temporal proximity to the issue being examined.
A development matters when it is capable of affecting the factual or evidentiary basis for continued designation.
ISDC does not begin a review with a preferred recommendation. Each case may lead to one of four defined outcomes.
Acceptance of information, communication with an applicant or the opening of a review does not create an obligation to recommend delisting. The same evidentiary standards apply regardless of who submitted the case.
ISDC publishes the standards governing its review process so that the basis of its work can be examined independently.