Assessment Preliminary Assessment
Following a review of the publicly available EU legal record, relevant judicial proceedings and material developments since the initial designation of Alisher Usmanov in February 2022, ISDC considers that the continued application of restrictive measures should be subject to an individual and evidence-based reassessment.
The EU designation has been examined through subsequent legal acts and judicial proceedings. In September 2025, the General Court examined the continued listing of Mr. Usmanov and addressed, among other matters, the legal basis of the designation, the evidence relied upon by the Council, the obligation to state reasons and the proportionality of the measures. The action was dismissed.
Mr. Usmanov subsequently brought an appeal before the Court of Justice in November 2025. The appeal, Case C-725/25 P, was discontinued in June 2026 and removed from the Court’s register in July 2026.
The current review takes place against the background of renewed discussions within the European Union concerning the continuation of individual restrictive measures.
ISDC does not consider the passage of time alone to constitute sufficient grounds for either continued designation or delisting.
Continued restrictive measures should remain supported by current, relevant and sufficiently substantiated grounds.
Accordingly, ISDC considers that the available record warrants a specific reassessment of whether the factual and legal circumstances supporting the continued application of the measures remain applicable at the present time.
This preliminary assessment does not determine the legal status of Mr. Usmanov and does not constitute a recommendation to any competent authority.
Institutional Independence Independence
ISDC’s assessment has been conducted independently of the EU decision-making process.
ISDC does not impose, administer, maintain, suspend or remove sanctions.
Following the conclusion of the current EU review period, ISDC may publish a final assessment taking into account any subsequent official decision and relevant developments.
Following the publication of this preliminary assessment, the Council of the European Union completed its review of the relevant individual restrictive measures.
On 22 September 2026, the Council decided not to renew the listing of Alisher Usmanov under the EU restrictive-measures framework concerning actions undermining or threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine.
His entry was consequently removed from the Annex to Decision 2014/145/CFSP.
This subsequent development changes the EU sanctions status recorded at the time of the preliminary assessment. The assessment above is retained as a record of ISDC’s analysis as of 15 September 2026.